AI Series, Part I: Why Some Lawyers Will Thrive in the Age of AI
As AI becomes part of everyday workflows in almost every industry, I’m often asked whether it will “replace” lawyers. My answer is actually the opposite: AI is making great lawyers even more essential.
A recent matter at our firm illustrated this perfectly.
We've seen a sharp uptick in data-subject-access requests. Recently, one of our clients received a particularly broad request from a former employee who had been involuntarily terminated. The demand swept in internal and confidential company records, and the tone and structure made it clear that the individual had some help from “AI counsel,” courtesy of ChatGPT.
Right away, we recognized a key issue: the jurisdiction in question doesn’t provide data-subject-access rights for private-sector employees. In other words, the entire request was based on a legal premise that didn’t exist.
Even so, we double-checked our conclusion using our own advanced legal research tools that also leverage cutting-edge AI. To our surprise, the tool insisted that the employer had to produce the documents. When we dug into the citations, we realized it relied on authority that applied only to certain government employees, not private companies.
We refined the prompt. The system doubled down. This time, the citations weren’t hallucinated, they were real, but the tool was misapplying the law by treating a pending state senate bill as if it were already enacted.
We advised the client correctly. The employee had no right to the documents. We crafted an appropriate response, averting the significant risk that blind compliance would have created.
This experience reinforced what every good lawyer knows: mastery isn't about memorizing statutes. It's knowing how to research, verify, and exercise judgment.
In the age of AI, that distinction matters more than ever.
AI is tremendously powerful when used correctly. But used blindly, it can create real exposure, unnecessary cost, and operational risk. Had our client relied solely on ChatGPT—or had we ignored our legal training and accepted the AI platform’s confident but incorrect analysis—the company could have disclosed sensitive information for no legal reason at all.
This is why I don’t believe AI is replacing lawyers. It’s elevating the value of lawyers who understand how to use it responsibly. The future belongs to lawyers who embrace technology, but never outsource their judgment.
This post was written by Sam Davidson and Joshua Rutstein and marks the first in a short series on how AI is reshaping the practice of law—its opportunities, its pitfalls, and how firms like ours stay at the cutting edge.